Short journal · Original editorial · Useful disagreement
Two proposals are argued over without being tested.
Agreement is easier to assess when the actual choice is visible. A disagreement can concern evidence, preference, timing, or limits. Name the point of difference before trying to settle it, and leave people room to revise their view.
Choose a small reversible comparison that addresses the disagreement.
Leave an easy return path where possible. Changing a method should not require pretending the earlier attempt never existed.
Try a question
What would you notice after trying this in one small, real situation?